FSRA Lic. #13722(416) 371-2077info@stonefieldcapital.ca

The CMHC fourplex program unlocks high-ratio financing, but insured lending doesn't erase personal liability. Dave Steinfeld breaks down the real risks: cost overruns, appraisal gaps, and what happens when the numbers don't hold.

Borrower Guides5 min read

Thinking About the CMHC Fourplex Play? Read This Before You Pull a Demo Permit

Thinking About the CMHC Fourplex Play? Read This Before You Pull a Demo Permit
D

David Steinfeld

Principal Broker at Stonefield Capital Inc., a private mortgage lender and FSRA-licensed mortgage brokerage (#13722), serving Ontario brokers, investors, and borrowers since 2018.

Share:

My feed has been full of it for months. Take a tired 75-year-old house worth $950,000, knock it down, build a four-unit, and collect rent forever. The pitch sounds almost too clean: a federal program unlocks high-ratio insured financing, the stabilized value hits $3 million on paper, and the numbers sing. Retirement by fifty. Financial freedom. Everyone gets a fourplex.

I'm not saying the opportunity isn't real. I'm saying the people promoting it on Instagram aren't the ones who'll be on the hook when it goes sideways. You are.

The Federal Program Does Not Absorb Your Risk

Here's what most people miss: insured financing means the mortgage gets paid if you default. It does not mean your personal liability disappears. When you sign for a construction loan and a takeout mortgage on a fourplex conversion, you are personally on the hook for every dollar that falls through the cracks between the pro forma and reality.

The government made it easier to build. It did not make it easier to absorb a cost overrun, a delayed occupancy permit, or a stabilized appraisal that comes in $400,000 below what you modelled. That gap lands on your balance sheet. Not Ottawa's.

This distinction matters enormously because the program was designed to increase housing supply, not to protect individual developers from bad project economics. Those are two completely different things, and conflating them is how good people get into serious financial trouble.

Inflated Paper Values Are Not the Same as Real Exit Values

The $3 million stabilized value is a projection. It assumes the rents come in, the market holds, and a buyer or a lender agrees with your numbers at the end of the build. If the value comes in lower, the math collapses, and your personal property and assets absorb the shortfall.

This is not a theoretical risk. Construction costs routinely run past initial pro formas. Rents in a given pocket of Mississauga or Barrie don't always match what a spreadsheet built in January predicts for an October completion. And if the stabilized appraisal doesn't support the takeout financing you planned, you don't get to renegotiate the federal program. You get a capital call.

The people salivating at the equity math on a fourplex conversion need to ask a harder question: if the value comes back at $2.4 million instead of $3 million, what do I liquidate to cover the gap? Because that's not a hypothetical. That's a scenario you need to have funded before you pull a demo permit.

Development Financing Is Not a Hobby

This is where the second problem compounds the first. Private lending grew fast enough that experienced voices in the industry are openly asking how many undocumented problems are still building beneath the surface. Where there's smoke, there's fire. And a fast-growing niche full of underprepared participants is exactly the environment where amateur structures get papered over until they can't be.

What's true for lenders is equally true for borrowers. A developer who treats their first fourplex like a home renovation project, managed loosely with a builder cousin and a broker who sourced the deal on a referral, is not running a development project. They're running a lottery ticket. With personal recourse attached.

The builders who do this well over multiple cycles treat financing as a core competency, not an afterthought. They know their draw schedule before the first excavator shows up. They know what triggers a revaluation. They know the exact conditions under which the lender can slow or stop advances, and they have contingency capital ready when that happens.

The Draw Schedule Is Where Projects Actually Succeed or Fail

When Stonefield structures a construction mortgage, the draw schedule is agreed at commitment and sized to the build. Each advance requires the previous phase to be complete and installed on site: concrete poured and cured, framing up, windows in. Materials sitting in a supplier's warehouse don't count. The money follows verified work, not aspirational timelines.

Until the foundation, framing, and roof are closed in, the project is valued as land. After that, it's valued as-is, and the available advance rises as phases complete. The as-completed value shapes the commitment and the exit, but advances never get ahead of the current state of the building.

That discipline protects the borrower as much as the lender. A developer who understands this structure going in doesn't get surprised at draw three when the lender sends an inspector and the advance comes back short. They planned for it. They're not scrambling to cover payroll for the framing crew from a personal line of credit while they argue about progress.

The Personal Liability Piece Is the One Nobody Talks About

Let me say this plainly, because the fourplex content online doesn't: you are personally liable. If the rents don't cover the debt service at stabilization, you are personally liable. If you can't sell the finished building for the price the pro forma required, you are personally liable. If a cost overrun blows your contingency and you need a bridge, the lender will want collateral, and that collateral may be your home.

This is not a reason to avoid the play. It is a reason to structure it properly before you start. If the deal only works at the top number, it doesn't actually work. If your contingency is 5% of construction cost and the industry standard for a GTA infill project is closer to 15%, you're not conservative. You're exposed.

The question to ask before you sign anything is not "what does this look like if everything goes right?" It's "what does my balance sheet look like if three things go wrong at once?" If the answer is "I lose the house I'm living in," that's a risk profile you need to know before the demo permit, not after.

The Bottom Line

The fourplex program is real, and the opportunity is real for the right builder with the right project and the right financing structure. The pitch circulating online isn't wrong about the upside. It's just silent about the personal liability, the cost variance risk, the appraisal gap risk, and what happens when the stabilized value doesn't support the exit.

Builders and developers who succeed over multiple cycles do it because they pressure-test the deal before the shovel goes in. They work with financing partners who understand draw mechanics, who value collateral conservatively, and who tell them the uncomfortable number early, not at closing. That's the difference between a fourplex that builds wealth and one that becomes the most expensive lesson of your financial life.

If you have a fourplex conversion in front of you and you want someone to run the numbers honestly, not cheerfully, reach out. No pitch, no pressure. Just a straight conversation about whether the deal actually works.

David Steinfeld, Stonefield Capital, Richmond Hill
stonefieldcapital.ca | 416-371-2077

D

David Steinfeld

David Steinfeld is the Principal Broker at Stonefield Capital Inc., a private mortgage lender and FSRA-licensed mortgage brokerage (#13722), serving Ontario brokers, investors, and borrowers since 2018.

Share:
Broker Share Kit & AI Writer →

Social media templates, email templates, and AI personalization tools for this article.

Have Questions About Your Situation?

Whether you're a broker with a deal or a borrower looking for options, we can help.

Get Market Insights Delivered

Join 500+ Ontario mortgage professionals who receive our monthly market wrap-up. Rate updates, deal trends, and private lending analysis.